Management audit and organization development
A management audit refers to evaluation of the competencies as well as capabilities of a firm’s management in undertaking corporate objectives. The primary purpose of a management audit is not assessment of individual performance of executives, instead it includes assessment of effectiveness of the management team in preserving the shareholders’ interests, maintaining strong and enduring relations with the employees, and keeping up repute. It is imperative that the management audit evaluates the entire management of the organization, not the performance of individual managers.
It takes into consideration both financial as well as non-financial factors. For example, it covers business organizational objectives, efficacies of the administration, economic environment, organization framework, various elements of organisational departments, its operations, control procedures, and usage of physical facilities and human resources.
The audit is not a new or recent idea. History tells us of the presence of auditors in Pharaoh’s Egypt and the classical periods of Greek and Roman history. As businesses developed and grew over the centuries of recorded history, the need for controls became increasingly important. Financial auditing became a standard in American businesses and, following the lead of New York State, certification for accountants was enacted as legislation in many states. The financial audit is now fully integrated into business practices. The internal audit follows the spirit of financial auditing and surpasses it to examine operational matters as well. Another natural extension is operational auditing. While internal auditing is conducted by employees within the organization, an operational audit is generally completed by an internal task force or external analysts.
The management audit is now widely accepted in the business field. For more than 40 years, corporations and nonprofit organizations have utilized the management audit as a comprehensive tool. In 1932 T. G. Rose, a lecturer in management at Cambridge University and former manager for Leyland Motors, embraced the concept of an annual organizational and management audit; Queens University School of Business professor William P. Leonard followed suit, urging a comprehensive examination of the business entity. Additional credibility stemmed from the General Accounting Office of the federal government, an office charged with independent audits of government agencies.
The management audit is defined by its scope and objectives. The scope is broad and generally includes all functions of the organization, including objectives and strategy, corporate structure, organizational planning, the budgeting process, human and financial resources management, decision making, research and development, marketing, equipment and operations, and management information systems . This breadth extends to recent, present, and future operations and covers external issues as well as internal concerns. Objectives of the management audit include the development of recommendations and improvements, as well as increased awareness of the credibility and acceptance of the audit’s results. The process is more an audit of management, in order to enhance corporate profits and financial stability.
An important aspect of the management audit is the composition of the study team. Both internal and external analysts are frequently used on audit teams; the composition depends on several factors, including the need for independent appraisal, the lack of human or financial resources to conduct the audit, and the need to provide an external audit to contrast against internal findings. In some instances, associations such as the American Institute of Management (AIM) provide audit teams.
The AIM has developed ten categories of the management audit, and many audits apply these same categories. They include:
– Economic function
– Corporate structure
– Health of earnings
– Service to stockholders
– Research and development
– Directorate analysis
– Fiscal policies
– Production efficiency
-Sales vigor
– Executive evaluation
Management audits are not limited to business corporations. Nonprofit organizations—including educational institutions, hospitals, and churches—often use the management audit to attempt to improve operations. When conducted effectively, and when recommendations are applied properly, the management audit has proved its usefulness as a management technique.
Objectives of Management Audit:
– To present recommendations to improve efficiency: Management audit detects incompetency in different echelons of management and suggests methods for improvement of efficiencies.
– To test and validate efficiency: Management audit aims at improving productivity at different levels of management and implementation of policies.
– To analyse the overall ability of strategies, policies and planning: It audits and analyses the policies processes structured by the management and reviews if it is suitably implemented.
– To increase profit: It assists in increasing the profit margin of the business by presenting solutions to optimize the resources in a valuable manner.
